4/13/2011

More Chinese Bidder Concerns

Over the past few weeks I have posted to the AW Blog on concerns of non-payment by winning bidders of Chinese art from various auction houses. The three main issues were the bronze animal heads from the YSL sale, payment or lack thereof for the Qainlong vase from Bainbridges and recent new requirements for deposits at the recent Hong Kong sales at Sotheby's for bidders on premium lots.

The Antiques Trade Gazette is now reporting that French auction houses are now also starting to require deposits and agreements to payment terms in order to bid. Toulouse auction houses is requiring a euro 200,000 deposit to bid on select items of Chinese art.

The ATG article also states Bainbridges has yet to be paid and is sending an attorney to China to try to collect or negotiate payment terms.

The ATG reports

FRENCH auction houses have toughened their stance on Chinese bidders after a series of well-publicised problems with non-payment.

Toulouse auction houses led the way when offering two important Qianlong works of art for sale on March 26.

A 79ft (24m) scroll of a military procession dating from 1739, was expected to bring €3m-4m at Marc Labarbe, sufficient for Pierre Ansas, the freelance Asian art specialist who catalogued the sale, to ask potential buyers for a returnable deposit of €200,000 to allow them to bid at the sale.

The one European and seven Asian bidders who registered to bid also contracted to pay one third of the premium-inclusive price within a week and the balance of the bill within three months if they were successful.

The same rules applied to bidders for an Imperial white jade seal offered on the same day by fellow Toulouse auctioneers Chassaing-Marambat.

M. Ansas conceded the move – which auction body Symev confirmed is not common practice in France – was unpopular, but he was not prepared to risk falling victim to a non-paying bidder of the type that has blighted the sale of the £43m vase at Bainbridge's of West Ruislip.

He told the Bloomberg news wire: "I need to be responsible. I have a business to run. I would rather have sold the scroll for €8m-10m to someone with money in the bank, rather than for a crazy price to someone I don't know."

He added that the agent representing the Liaoning-based real estate billionaire Wang Jianlin – recently identified by dealers as the successful bidder at Bainbridge's in November – had been refused permission to register for the sale.

In an effort to resolve the payment issues surrounding their record-breaking vase, auctioneer Peter Bainbridge and owner retired solicitor Anthony Johnson from the Isle of Wight, were reported to have flown to China to meet the buyer of the most expensive Chinese work of art ever sold.

I posted most of the ATG article, but if you wish to visit the source article , click HERE.


TAKE THE SURVEY – Don’t forget to take the Appraiser Workshops Fine and Decorative Arts Market Survey.  Click HERE to be part of the survey. Participation in the survey has been very good, and the more input we have, the stronger and more significant the results.  Please take a few minutes and complete the online survey.  The free results will be posted on the AW Blog, and will be available for download.  Click HERE to take the survey. 

No comments: